To provide insight into the iron(IV)hydroxide pKa of histidine ligated heme proteins, we have probed the active site of myoglobin compound II over the pH range of 3.9–9.5, using EXAFS, Mössbauer, and resonance Raman spectroscopies. We find no indication of ferryl protonation over this pH range, allowing us to set an upper limit of 2.7 on the iron(IV)hydroxide pKa in myoglobin. Together with the recent determination of an iron(IV)hydroxide pKa ∼ 12 in the thiolate-ligated heme enzyme cytochrome P450, this result provides insight into Nature’s ability to tune catalytic function through its choice of axial ligand.

A class Ia ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) employs a μ-oxo-Fe2III/III/tyrosyl radical cofactor in its β subunit to oxidize a cysteine residue ∼35 Å away in its α subunit; the resultant cysteine radical initiates substrate reduction. During self-assembly of the Escherichia coli RNR-β cofactor, reaction of the protein’s Fe2II/II complex with O2 results in accumulation of an Fe2III/IV cluster, termed X, which oxidizes the adjacent tyrosine (Y122) to the radical (Y122•) as the cluster is converted to the μ-oxo-Fe2III/III product. As the first high-valent non-heme-iron enzyme complex to be identified and the key activating intermediate of class Ia RNRs, X has been the focus of intensive efforts to determine its structure. Initial characterization by extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy yielded a Fe–Fe separation (dFe–Fe) of 2.5 Å, which was interpreted to imply the presence of three single-atom bridges (O2–, HO–, and/or μ-1,1-carboxylates). This short distance has been irreconcilable with computational and synthetic models, which all have dFe–Fe ≥ 2.7 Å. To resolve this conundrum, we revisited the EXAFS characterization of X. Assuming that samples containing increased concentrations of the intermediate would yield EXAFS data of improved quality, we applied our recently developed method of generating O2 in situ from chlorite using the enzyme chlorite dismutase to prepare X at ∼2.0 mM, more than 2.5 times the concentration realized in the previous EXAFS study. The measured dFe–Fe = 2.78 Å is fully consistent with computational models containing a (μ-oxo)2-Fe2III/IV core. Correction of the dFe–Fe brings the experimental data and computational models into full conformity and informs analysis of the mechanism by which X generates Y122•.

This Forum focuses on the nature of the elusive oxidizing intermediate in P450 catalysis. The identity of this species has reemerged as a topic of contentious debate. It was recently reported that laser flash photolysis (LFP) can be used to generate P450 compound I (P450-I) quantitatively. Kinetic analyses of the reaction of the LFP-generated intermediate with substrates have been suggested to indicate that compound I is not the active oxidant in P450 catalysis. We evaluate these claims via an analysis of the UV/visible spectrum of the LFP-generated intermediate. The techniques of singular value decomposition and target testing are used to obtain the spectrum of P450-I in a model-independent manner from stopped-flow data of the reaction of P450 with m-chloroperbenzoic acid. It is shown that the LFP-generated spectrum bears no similarity to the P450-I spectrum. One may conclude that the LFP-generated intermediate is not P450-I.

Aliphatic halogenases activate O2, cleave α-ketoglutarate (αKG) to CO2 and succinate, and form haloferryl [X−Fe(IV)═O; X = Cl or Br] complexes that cleave aliphatic C−H bonds to install halogens during the biosynthesis of natural products by non-ribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPSs). For the related αKG-dependent dioxygenases, it has been shown that reaction of the Fe(II) cofactor with O2 to form the C−H bond-cleaving ferryl complex is “triggered” by binding of the target substrate. In this study, we have tested for and defined structural determinants of substrate triggering (ST) in the halogenase, SyrB2, from the syringomycin E biosynthetic NRPS of Pseudomonas syringae B301D. As for other halogenases, the substrate of SyrB2 is complex, consisting of l-Thr tethered via a thioester linkage to a covalently bound phosphopantetheine (PPant) cofactor of a carrier protein, SyrB1. Without an appended amino acid, SyrB1 does not trigger formation of the chloroferryl intermediate state in SyrB2, even in the presence of free l-Thr or its analogues, but SyrB1 charged either by l-Thr (l-Thr-S-SyrB1) or by any of several non-native amino acids does trigger the reaction by as much as 8000-fold (for the native substrate). Triggering efficacy is sensitive to the structures of both the amino acid and the carrier protein, being diminished by 5−24-fold when the native l-Thr is replaced with another amino acid and by ∼40-fold when SyrB1 is replaced with the heterologous carrier protein, CytC2. The directing effect of the carrier protein and consequent tolerance for profound modifications to the target amino acid allow the chloroferryl state to be formed in the presence of substrates that perturb the ratio of its two putative coordination isomers, lack the target C−H bond (l-Ala-S-SyrB1), or contain a C−H bond of enhanced strength (l-cyclopropylglycyl-S-SyrB1). For the latter two cases, the SyrB2 chloroferryl state so formed exhibits unprecedented stability (t1/2 = 30−110 min at 0 °C), can be trapped at high concentration and purity by manual freezing without a cryosolvent, and represents an ideal target for structural characterization. As initial steps toward this goal, extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy has been used to determine the Fe−O and Fe−Cl distances and density functional theory (DFT) calculations have been used to confirm that the measured distances are consistent with the anticipated structure of the intermediate.

We report direct evidence for the existence of an iron(IV)–hydroxide. Resonance Raman measurements on chloroperoxidase compound II (CPO-II) reveal an isotope (18O and 2H)-sensitive band at νFe–O = 565 cm−1. Preparation of CPO-II in H2O using H2 18O2 results in a red-shift of 22 cm−1, while preparation of CPO-II in 2H2O using H2O2 results in a red-shift of 13 cm−1. These values are in good agreement with the isotopic shifts predicted (23 and 12 cm−1, respectively) for an Fe–OH harmonic oscillator. The measured Fe–O stretching frequency is also in good agreement with the 1.82-Å Fe–O bond reported for CPO-II. A Badger’s rule analysis of this distance provides an Fe–O stretching frequency of νBadger = 563 cm−1. We also present X-band electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) data for cryoreduced CPO-II. Cryogenic reduction (77 K) of the EPR-silent Fe(IV)OH center in CPO-II results in an EPR-active Fe(III)OH species with a strongly coupled (13.4 MHz) exchangeable proton. Based on comparisons with alkaline myoglobin, we assign this resonance to the hydroxide proton of cryoreduced CPO-II.

We report the structural characterization of a thiolate-ligated ferryl radical. Using x-ray absorption spectroscopy, we examined chloroperoxidase (CPO) compound I (CPO-I). Our results indicate that CPO-I is an authentic ferryl species with an Fe–O bond of 1.65 Å. Axial-ligand interactions result in a remarkably long 2.48-Å Fe–S bond. Analogous forms of cytochrome P450 and CPO have been shown to possess virtually identical coordination environments. Thus, it seems likely that our findings provide a good structural description of the elusive P450-I.

We report the structural characterization of a thiolate-ligated ferryl radical. Using x-ray absorption spectroscopy, we examined chloroperoxidase (CPO) compound I (CPO-I). Our results indicate that CPO-I is an authentic ferryl species with an Fe–O bond of 1.65 Å. Axial-ligand interactions result in a remarkably long 2.48-Å Fe–S bond. Analogous forms of cytochrome P450 and CPO have been shown to possess virtually identical coordination environments. Thus, it seems likely that our findings provide a good structural description of the elusive P450-I.

Addition of anionic donors to the manganese(V)–oxo corrolazine complex MnV(O)(TBP8Cz) has a dramatic influence on oxygen-atom transfer (OAT) reactivity with thioether substrates. The six-coordinate anionic [MnV(O)(TBP8Cz)(X)]− complexes (X = F–, N3–, OCN–) exhibit a ∼5 cm–1 downshift of the Mn–O vibrational mode relative to the parent MnV(O)(TBP8Cz) complex as seen by resonance Raman spectroscopy. Product analysis shows that the oxidation of thioether substrates gives sulfoxide product, consistent with single OAT. A wide range of OAT reactivity is seen for the different axial ligands, with the following trend determined from a comparison of their second-order rate constants for sulfoxidation: five-coordinate ≈ thiocyanate ≈ nitrate < cyanate < azide < fluoride ≪ cyanide. This trend correlates with DFT calculations on the binding of the axial donors to the parent MnV(O)(TBP8Cz) complex. A Hammett study was performed with p-X-C6H4SCH3 derivatives and [MnV(O)(TBP8Cz)(X)]− (X = CN– or F–) as the oxidant, and unusual “V-shaped” Hammett plots were obtained. These results are rationalized based upon a change in mechanism that hinges on the ability of the [MnV(O)(TBP8Cz)(X)]− complexes to function as either an electrophilic or weak nucleophilic oxidant depending upon the nature of the para-X substituents. For comparison, the one-electron-oxidized cationic MnV(O)(TBP8Cz•+) complex yielded a linear Hammett relationship for all substrates (ρ = −1.40), consistent with a straightforward electrophilic mechanism. This study provides new, fundamental insights regarding the influence of axial donors on high-valent MnV(O) porphyrinoid complexes.